Back to the Future

Back To The Future

Picture this, a courtroom somewhere in France in the early 16th century.  A sharpwitted lawyer struts across the floor, waving his hand nonchalantly in the air as he eloquently champions the defence of his client.  But his client, or rather clients are nowhere to be seen.  Yet due to his clever ‘wordsmithory’ and ingenious legal tactics, Bartholomé Chassenée was able to convince the learned judge his clients fears for their life were justifiably held and as such that they could not attend (the presence of neighbourhood cats proving far too threatening).  That those on trial in this instance were rats, was not particularly unusual, for at the time medieval courts were well known to put animals on trial for crimes.   What is on note is that it has taken several more centuries before we have revisited the idea of legal representation for animals.

Fast forward to 1993 and The Great Ape Project (GAP) was founded as a group of primatologists, anthropologists, ethicists, and others advocated for a United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Great Apes that would confer basic legal rights on non-human great apes.  One year earlier, Switzerland amended its constitution so that animals were acknowledged as “beings” rather than things.  And more recently in Switzerland, a national referendum was held to decide if animals should have the constitutional right to be represented by lawyers in court in cases of animal mistreatment.   In 1999 New Zealand granted basic rights to five great ape species which forbade their use in research, testing or teaching.   On February 28, 2007 the parliament of the Balearic Islands, an autonomous community of Spain, passed the world’s first legislation that would effectively grant legal personhood rights to all great apes.  In 2002 in German law recognised “that animals, like humans, have the right to be respected by the state and to have their dignity protected”.  While it may be some time for this to bring meaningful changes for animals, the tide is clearly turning as animal law courses are now being offered by more and more universities and lawyers are forming advocacy groups for animals.

Although much recent focus has been on the protection of the ‘rights’ of primates, the question is now being posed as to whether our current treatment of animals is just and fair.  And in the cold stark reality of a fair and just world, today’s legal protection of animals is anything but just.  With the Darwinian theory of biological continuity seeing animals as different in degree, not kind, we clearly have been guilty of playing favorites.   And while the question of ‘personhood’ for animals can be debated until the cows come home, or rather go where ever they choose, the fundamental fact remains that regardless of the shape an animal is, regardless of our familiarity with a particular species and regardless of the way we humans ‘use’ them, all animals feel happiness and joy, all animals feel sadness, loneliness and pain and all animals deserve a life free from human inflicted pain and suffering.  Granted the Medieval judiciary may have transgressed the boundaries of common sense but granting animals their day in court may just be something whose time has come.

Make a donation

14 thoughts on “Back to the Future

  1. That’s so true Pam, it’s about time the world woke up to the suffering and pain we inflict upon innocence, usually for our gratification. So many humans walk around in a haze of self entitlement, not acknowledging the inconsistencies of humanity and the double standards they live in every single day. Thank goodness for beings such as yourself and your volunteers, who strive daily to bring awareness and clarity to the world, and who care for and speak up for the innocent.

  2. May that day in court come soon, and may the animals be handed a resounding win that sets a precedent that will help us evolve into the kinder, better species we have the potential to be!

  3. The French are currently changing the status of dogs…not sure if only dogs…..rather than a disposable thing, they now have rights.

  4. If we cant extend the hand of kindness, compassion and respect to our own species (asylum seekers, homeless, destitute), I have grave doubts about our ability to extend it to other species…

  5. I am so happy know that you are there taking care of these beautiful creatures, and spreading the word far and wide in regards to their Rights.
    We here at Hamilton Heritage are so happy being able to share your doings and spreading the word in regards to what you are doing for the Animals.

  6. Everyday we see examples of why animals need a human voice to represent them.
    I will be shouting from the docks.
    For the love of animals…..

  7. I think this will be the decade for animal rights because of the work you and your team at Edgars Mission are doing and the exposure of animal cruelty shown by Animals Australia. All of you are CHAMPIONS!!

  8. Laws to protect animals are vastly overdue. Thanks for all your work at Edgars Mission. Go for it Animals Australia too.

  9. The Veganists-Rawtarians-Fruitarians-vegetarians new and old members are converting friends, family, colleagues, strangers into a better world of kindness to animals. Actors, writers, producers (Noah-movie), politicians, senators, musical-artists and people like yourselves (Edgars Mission / Farm Sanctuary / The Gentle Barn & others) are causing shame to the factory-farm industry which cause previous uneducated meat-eaters to take a deeper look into the cruelty of the meat-industry and because of that change their lifestyles into non-meat-dairy lifestyles. It is enough proof to me that humans have on their DNA the basic message that meat-eating is carnal/sinful/cannibalistic & cruel, but they have been desensitized to that fact through their upbringing. Thank you for educating young and old through your mission that animals have the exact same needs as humans, love, companionship, shelter, food, in some animal species even life-long fidelity. May good overcome evil and animal rights (for ALL animals) become a basic right for farm animals also.

  10. That any human could ignore (or cause) the suffering of animals and not do anything about caring for and protecting them just shows that some humans are less evolved than others. The development of empathy and respect for all living beings is a sign of progress and I believe justice through the legal system will come, I just hope soon!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *