Around 265 BC, a Greek scholar and mathematician named Archimedes dipped his toe into a tub at the public baths in Syracuse, with his leg following suit. In doing this, Archimedes watched the water level rise. Lowering himself more fully into the water, he saw it continue to do so, ultimately spilling over the sides of the bath. At this point, Archimedes recognised that the volume of water displaced must be equal to the volume of the part of his body that had been submerged.

So excited about this discovery was Archimedes that he immediately jumped out of the bath and ran all the way home crying out, “Eureka, eureka,” which is Greek for “I have found it, I have found it”. In his glee, Archimedes failed to find his clothes and he ran home stark naked. However, what Archimedes was referring to was a way to determine the answer to a problem he had been posed by Hiero of Syracuse on how to assess the purity of gold in a golden crown.

Many civilizations on, and the word eureka is still synonymous with those “ah-ha”, “light-bulb” moments we have. You know—that moment when from nowhere comes a notion that allows you to finally connect the dots, and suddenly things are entirely clear. These spontaneous insights often come at random moments when you least expect it, like shopping for groceries, watching a movie, or like Archimedes getting into a bath. For me, my most profound eureka moment came in June 1986 when my ethics and actions collided, but thankfully for my neighbours and me, it didn’t send me racing down the street stark naked, although it did send me racing to the supermarket fully clothed to restock our cupboards and freezer. I was a bright-eyed and enthusiastic animal lover who thought she was living and leading a pretty good life caring for animals and making the world a kinder place. However, it was upon reading about Peter Singer’s encounter at a chapter of the RSPCA, where ham sandwiches were served for lunch and the noted philosopher mused, “How odd,” that I thought “Eureka—how right,” and my life and menu changed forever.

Scientists and psychologists have studied these eureka moments for around a century in an attempt to discover where they originate in the brain. New insights have shown they result from a complex series of brain states. And my mind has been pinging them out since that most incredible one way back in 1986, all shaping my life and thoughts in ways I could not have imagined, not the least being that creating a not-for-profit sanctuary for rescued farmed animals, giving up my secure paid job and rarely having a set of clean clothes would be the craziest yet most rewarding thing I would ever do. And in doing so, I have found that Archimedes, myself and all humans are not alone in having our eureka moments.

In 2004, Cambridge University Professor Donald Broom showed, by use of an electroencephalograph, that the brainwaves of cows showed they experience “ah-ha” moments when they completed a mental challenge. Broom reported: “The brainwaves showed their excitement; their heartbeat went up and some even jumped into the air. We called it their Eureka moment.”

In fact, in the last ten years, science has been coming down on the side of common sense, biological continuity and compassion regarding our understanding of how animals perceive their worlds and that they indeed too have eureka moments. Chickens, the most abundant animal on the planet, are rewriting just what it means to be bird-brained. Our very own Little Miss Sunshine has shown an amazing (although if you really do know chickens, it is not all that amazing) ability to display cognition that rivals that of three-year-old children through what is known as object permanence: the ability to understand that an object exists even if it has been taken away. Little Miss Sunshine has also learned to peck out the numbers shown on a randomly rolled dice, and even how to ring a bell when she wants to come inside. I think the most amazing thing about Little Miss Sunshine is that she was never preened for these things. In fact, had it not been for the eureka moment of the battery hen farmer who had a change of heart upon realising just how cruel it is to imprison hens in cages, she never would have. He wanted to exit the industry, but he did not wish for his hens to exit the world; that was where Edgar’s Mission came in, and one by precious one we rescued all of his hens from their tiny wire prisons.

It comes as no surprise for people like me, who work with farmed animals in sanctuary settings, that these animals have rich emotional worlds, and that they form friendships like Lombard the sheep and his best friend Jewel. Now, theirs is a really interesting story. Lombard and Jewel arrived at the sanctuary about the same time several years ago. Jewel had terrible deformities in her feet that had become afflicted with debilitating and painful infections, so bad that she was unable to stand, whilst Lombard was a gaunt young wether who was terrified of humans. But together they found comfort and became inseparable. Recently, Jewel had a flare-up of an old injury and was moved to an adjoining paddock so she could come in each night for rest and observation. As they had both been in with other sheep, we felt they would be secure enough not to need the constant company of one another. But not long afterwards, Lombard appeared very lame; we couldn’t find the reason for his lameness, so he too was brought into our hospital paddock for closer monitoring. Within a matter of moments, he had made his way past the other sheep and found Jewel. And lost his lameness. If I had not witnessed this myself, I would have thought the story was a fabrication, but it is not. Watching the two of them together, it is more than apparent they have the strongest of bonds—they are best friends forever.

There can be no doubt that the farmed animals I see every day experience pleasure, pain, joy, have long memories and even hold grudges. Like dear Edgar, who never forgave the very tall grey-haired vet who gave him his first injection. Whenever the vet returned to the farm, Edgar would race off screaming as only he could. These are animals who can learn from one another; they are ingenious and resourceful; and, of course, they love their babies. None of the residents of Edgar’s Mission better encapsulate this love than one-time dairy cow Clarabelle and her love for her baby, Valentine, whom she hid from us for several days after birth for fear that Valentine would be taken away, just as all Clarabelle’s previous babies had been. Even today, as Valentine edges towards maturity, the two of them can be seen together: Clarabelle lovingly licking sweet Valentine. Interestingly, when hearing the reason Clarabelle’s previous babies had been removed from her—so the milk she intended for her baby could be harvested for human consumption, with the fate of the baby calf uncertain at best—many have had their eureka moment and sworn off dairy products for life.

Farmed animals repeatedly show they understand cause and effect: our pigs and their operation of their showers demonstrate this beautifully. Suitably, our first pig to work this out was Albert Einswine, who learned quickly that pushing a lever caused the water to flow—a welcome reward on a hot summer’s day. And the fact his buddies have caught on too shows they are able to learn from the experiences of others. They can be curious, brave, shy, nervous, cheeky and timid. And while some are incredibly intelligent, some are not so, just like we humans. Yet, each and every single one is a unique individual who cherishes their life just as much as you and I.

In short, they are aware, and of this so should we be as well, and perhaps in doing so we will recognise the urgent need to revisit our relationship with the animal kingdom: our kin in another skin. That, my friend, could well be our greatest eureka moment, and we even get to keep our clothes on.

Make a donation

18 thoughts on “Eureka

    • that’s what it takes, a eureka moment when we figure it out, or have it pointed out, join the disconnected parts and no longer participate in that which is so wrong on every level

  1. Wonderful article as usual Pam. The awful thing that kept going through my mind as I was reading is how these feeling and intelligent animals feel when they are to be slaughtered. I will never understand how humans are ok with how we treat, kill and eat animals.

  2. Another great article Pam. Entertaining and thought provoking. I’m already a convert having had my eureka moment at a spit roast when I was 13.

  3. Very touching article. My eureka moment was Nov. 2013 and can’t believe it took that long. Our world makes this “normal” when in fact it couldn’t be more the opposite. Blessed are you for all you do for the animals!

  4. Thank you Pam, for your beautiful sentiments and your beautiful words. I’m forever grateful that our “kin in another skin” have you on their side.

  5. Beautifullly written Pam and Valentine’s story was indeed my Eureka moment. I’d been vegetarian for 30 years but had never really thought about the harm I was doing consuming dairy. It was so much easier than I thought it would be going vegan. Thank you for enlightening me.

  6. It’s always a huge pleasure reading your pieces Pam. As a result of Edgar’s Mission and Animals Australia I am moving towards being fully vegan. Now every time I feel I must have some cheese, I think of Clarabelle and Valentine and curb the desire. To this point I have to admit to not finding an alternative that I enjoy, but I’ll keep trying.

    • Leonie, if you shop at Woolworths there some cheese called ‘bio cheese’ (cheddar flavour) which is delicious and cruelty free. Coles also sell bio cheese but it is just the plain flavour which by all accounts is better than eating dairy but personally I don’t think is as tasty as the Cheddar flavour.

    • Peace Lpve and Vegetables put out a jar of Cashew Cheese which is very Yummy. Good Medicine (USA) Magazine Winter 2017 has some great receipes for vegan cheese: See The Cheese Trap by Neal Barnard M.D. Reprinted in Good Med was the Tany Cashew Cheese recipe.

  7. I love EM and everything you stand for. Proud to be vegan. No cheese is worth the pain and suffering of dairy cows and their babies. I enjoy saying hello to my EM diary, such heart warming pics, the best start to each morning.

  8. Enjoy your writings. The names given your animals are truly a reflection of the love & thought that goes into the very being of Edgar’s Mission. Thank you for what you do.

  9. A wonderful article. I cried for Clarabelle at the thought of her having to hide her baby Valentine. Blessed are you for giving them both a safe haven..

  10. I always enjoy reading your “Trottings”, Pam. You are a very good writer, and should write a book. I am wondering if sometime I could talk to you about the possibility of using some of your material for the Australian Animal Protection Society’s ‘Newsletter”? You would be given due credit, and shown any copy first to edit. Of course I understand that you may not feel that it is what you want to do. My only wish is that all animals should have the good fortune to live in a farm place like yours.

  11. Lindo
    Este Quadro. as recuperação deste animais muito belo este trabalho de voces , uma ressocialização com o homem e o animal. senssacional. é um Goool de Placa nesta copa Mundial , no mundo, Animal.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *